Tuesday, 20 September 2022

A History of Hop Growing in Ireland - Revised & Expanded

[This was first published in three parts in 2021. This is a combined, revised and expanded version of those posts.]

“Historically, hops were not grown in Ireland ...”

Or so says an online encyclopaedia entry on hops, and although some people know this not to be true, the sentence is so often repeated in similar wording that I thought it would be best to do some myth-busting to highlight that hops were grown in this country in various quantities and were even used in commercial brewing.

This is a record of the history, mentions and other snippets of information pertaining to hop growing in this country, where I will show and prove that we have been growing hops in this country for the last 400 years at the very least in varying amounts and with various degrees of success, albeit not on the same scale as the bigger hop growing countries.

I will be doing so in a chronological timeline which might help others who are interested in the subject or need to reference it – I only ask that you credit me and my website if you use any of my research.

So, where do we start – the first date I can find mentioning actual hops is from the first half of the 17th century…

1632 - A quote in an article in The Transactions of the Royal Irish Academy, Volume 17 first published in 1830 and itself quoting an earlier source says that hops, along with other crops, were introduced to Ireland in 1632 'and grew very well.' Not exactly a verifiable source but it is certainly very conceivable that hops would have made their way here by this time, if not before.

1689 - The Calendar of Ancient Records of Dublin from this year and published in 1895 states that 'Flemish hops by retail not to exceed eighteen pence per pound. And English and Irish hops not to exceed two shillings and three pence per pound.’ This price-fixing exercise mentions the term Irish hops as distinct from Flemish or English ones, so is this an indicator of a reasonable crop being grown here? Perhaps not but it is a worthy reference...

1699 - A mention of ‘a duty on Irish Hops’ in this year in a version of The Continuation of Mr. Rapin's History of England from the Revolution to the Present Times by an N. Tindal and published in 1761. This duty could of course be covering the possibility of hops being grown here and exported but it certainly hints at there being a trade in Irish hops.

Pre-1727 - A comment from an English parliamentary discussion published in an English newspaper in 1886 says that 'In the reign of George I [1714-1727] a duty was imposed on Irish hops...' This might be confusion with an act passed in 1711 that prohibited the importation of hops into Ireland from anywhere except England but could equally refer to the above mentioned earlier duty. It is worth noting here that some of these references are looking back at events in the past so their accuracy must be questioned a little. It is also possible that this comment and those above refer to hops that were imported into the country before being exported again.

1729 - In his publication on the trade in this country John Carteret asks why we cultivate so little hops in Ireland given the huge quantity we import, and he states that we could raise good hops in the southern part of the country. He also says, 'that with some it has succeeded well', which would let us believe that there is a certain amount of production. He also claims that the issue of the lack of hop growing lies with the want of hop-poles as 'there are so few plantations or trees to be met with' that produce suitable hop-poles in Ireland.

1729 - In the same collection as above from that year Arthur Dobbs in his Essay on the Trade and Improvement of Ireland makes similar comments. He mentions that hops have been 'tried in several more northern counties with tolerable success.' He also goes on in some detail regarding the benefits of growing hops for both trade and employment.

1733 - The Dublin Society published a book of instruction on hop cultivation (link below). From the tone of this volume it appears that hops were not very common or plentiful here at this time, but certainly known. It also points out that hops were quite expensive to import and gives details of potential returns and instructions on raising poles for support, on harvesting and packaging.

This is probably a good time to mention the Dublin Society who feature heavily in the coming years. It was founded in 1731 and its remit was to encourage new trade and enterprise, and in doing so create more local industries to replace imported goods, and therefore create more employment here too. To aid in this it created what it termed ‘Premiums’ or rewards for those who achieved certain criteria of volume, application or excellence of certain Irish goods and produce. Its name was changed to the Royal Dublin Society in 1820, and most Irish people would be familiar with the acronym RDS.

1736 - In the Dublin Society's Weekly Observations published in 1737 there is a letter - one of many - that mentions beer made with 'Irish Hops and Irish Malts.' The writer goes on to say that in this country 'we are not arrived to any great perfection in the culture and management of hops; nevertheless, the year 1736, gave us sufficient proof that in a good season we may be supply'd from among ourselves with that valuable commodity.' The writer then goes on to extol the virtues of said Irish hops by comparing them with Kentish and Worcester hops and finding them equal of better. (He goes on to discuss boiling times and bitterness of hops - and hop stalks!)

1737 - Another writer in the same publication as above gives extremely detailed directions on 'the raising of hops in red bogs' in two letters, where he had 'reared them with most success' for the previous 15 years. He appears to have sold the hops as he says that 'the profit has for many years fully answered my expense.' This may be the first mention of commercial reward for a crop of hops in Ireland. Those 'red bogs' - seemingly - could not be reclaimed or used like 'black bogs', so they were ideal for the venture. He also mentions that these 'Bog-Hops' (His name for them …) were less prone to 'swarms of insects which too often infest our upland hops', implying that hops were being grown on other sites in the country.

1740 - A newspaper article from 1963 states that hop growing in Ireland goes back to about 1740 and the main centres were Offaly, Laois, North Tipperary and Kilkenny but it gives no references and so must be treated with caution, as it was being reported more than 200 years after the time, although it could be based on the Dublin Society reports that follow ...

1741 - A ‘Premium’ or reward is offered by the Dublin Society for '200lb weight of the best hops of Irish growth for that year’. - via The Gentleman's Magazine. (This award appears to have started in at least 1740 from snippet sources elsewhere online ...)

1741 - In December of this year the members of the Dublin Society met in Market House Thomas Street in Dublin to examine hops and give out premiums for the best and second-best parcels of Irish-grown hops. There were 22 candidates, so I presume 22 actual growers. 12 were judged not quite up to the standard of the 10 best, and those 10 were further examined for ‘Colour, Smell and Feeling’. They awarded first place to Mr Humphry Jones of Mullinbro in Co. Kilkenny - near Waterford - and the second to Edward Bolton of ‘Brasil’ (Brazil near Swords?) Co. Dublin. ‘The judges declared that Mr. Jones’s hops were as good as they ever saw brought from Kent.’ The total quantity supplied from all the entries was 45 hundred-weight (Over 2,250 kg?) and apart from 2 parcels all the rest were as good or better than those imported. Three other growers were singled out as next best - Anthony Atkinson from King’s County (now Offaly), Mr. Lee of Wexford and Samuel Ealy [Ely?] of Ross in County Wexford.

(The above was from a nice reference I found of a reprinted report by the Dublin Society in a newspaper from January of 1742. This and the other reports certainly show that we had a decent geographical spread of hop farms of a reasonable size – perhaps – around parts the country.)

1742 - The following year Mr. Humphry Jones again had the best parcel of 2 hundred-weight (2 hundredweight or approximately 100kg) of hops and received an award of 20 pounds. He had grown ‘65 C. 6 lb’ of hops (Is the ‘C’ in this case an abbreviation for Stone? I am not sure…) Most of his hops were sold to ‘brewers in Dublin’ and that they were ‘equal in all respects to any English or Irish Hops they had ever before made use of.’, which suggests that they were of good quality and that Irish hops had been used by commercial breweries before this time.

1743 - In an 1861 reprint of a report from this year Humphry Jones again took first prize, second was Samuel Ely, Ross, Co. Wexford and third was Mr. Sutton – no address given. The same report also gives an award to Thwaite’s brewery, Dublin for using ‘10 tons’ of Irish hops in their beers, William Bererton came second using '3 tons' in his brewery. More proof that Irish-grown hops were used in Irish beers in the 18th century.

1744 - The same reprint of above gives the award in this year to Samuel Ely and second place to Ephraim Dawson (no address given) – no sign of Mr. Jones!

c. 1746-1786 - A gentleman called George Stoney from 'Grayfort, near Borrosakean' wrote to the Dublin Society in 1786 saying he had a 'small plantation' of two acres of hops laid out 40 years previously by 'an Englishman' from which he gets two hundred-weight of hops. He goes on to say, 'If planting hops were carried on to proper effect, Ireland might well supply itself, and I experimentally know, that, when well cured, we may have as good as England produces. I yearly have brewed for my house upwards of forty barrels of malt, with my own hops, and my beer keeps as well, and is as well flavoured, as it would be with English hops.' - via Transactions of the Dublin Society, Volume 2, Part 1- 1801

1748 - A snippet mention in The Scots Magazine about a person needing to buy a great quantity of 'Irish hops' - not less than 4 ton.

1748 - Again the Dublin Society offered a premium ‘to the person who shall produce the best parcel of hops, not less than 200 weight, of the growth of 1748’ and also ‘to the person who shall buy up for sale, the greatest quantity of Irish hops of the growth of 1748, before May 15, 1749, not less than 4 tun. [sic]’ and finally ‘To the person who shall make use of the greatest quantity of ditto in brewing before June 1st 1749, not less than 3 tun, but no one person shall get both said premiums.’ – The Scots Magazine

1749 - A newspaper report states that Darius Drake of Camlin in Wexford won a reward from the Dublin Society for planting in 1747 'seven plantation acres and tree perches' with hops 'four to a hill, and 7538 hills at 8 feet distance from one another, and that they are in a thriving condition.' At the time this was alleged to be the greatest quantity of land given over to hop production by one person in the country. Mr. Drake produced poles for other growers in the country before deciding to grow his own hops - his own plantation required between '20 and 30,000' poles. It is claimed that many of his neighbours had large plantations also, just not large enough to win this 'premium' from the Dublin Society. I certainly feel that Mr. Drake deserves separate research to investigate both his hop and hop-pole growing.

1749 - The premiums for the three best parcels of hops were awarded this year to Humphrey Jones yet again, William Hamond from Ross in Wexford and Thomas Sutton from Wexford. They had 'good colour, flavour and strength.’ It was mentioned that Mr. Sutton dried his hops with both Kilkenny (Surely Castlecomer so?) coal and with charcoal, and those dried with charcoal had much better flavour!

1756 - Newspaper announcement for the reward for the best 3 parcels of hops not less than 200 weight and grown in that year.

1757 - Three bags of hops produced for a competition by the Dublin Society, each weighing two hundred-weight. The best was judged to be from a Mr. Nicholas Lanigan of Co. Kilkenny, second place went to a Mr. Christopher Antisel(?) of Tipperary, and the last parcel was unclaimed. The judges declared the first two parcels of hops equal to those imported from England.

1786 - There is a brief mention in an English newspaper of the bill to regulate the importation of hops from Ireland. This might not mean Irish grown hops of course - maybe just those passing through?!

1786 - Person named Bonner had a 4-acre hop yard in Naas according to an article called 'Ancient Naas and Neighbourhood’ by T.J. de Burgh written in 1893 and published in a Kildare newspaper that year.

1789 – An advertisement appears in Saunder’s News-Letter stating that a Mr. Simpson, a seed merchant on College Green in Dublin can supply plants for ‘two acres and upwards’ and that the Dublin Society will pay a premium for planting two acres of hops – twenty pounds in the first year and ten pounds in the next.

1789 -  A Dublin newspaper carries a statement that in 'some parts of this kingdom, hops grow to great perfection, and yet, if known to be Irish produce, not much above half that price will be given for them which those brought from Kent and other counties in England bring.' The writer goes on to say that they should thrive here and be used for home consumption as well as being exported. They also give a dig at the Americans, saying that even they are growing hops and establishing breweries although they 'formerly made no other drink but spruce beer and beverage expresses from the wild grape.'

1797 - The Dublin Society would be offering a premium for ‘beer brewed with Irish hops of the growth of the years 1796 and 1797, for private use or sale. The claims to be made by oath before 25th March 1797’ according to Walker's Hibernian Magazine or Compendium of the previous year.

So that finishes the 17th and 18th centuries, and we can see from all of these reports and mentions, and specifically those from the Dublin Society, that there was quite a decent quantity of hops being grown in this country, particularly in the middle of the 18th century. The figures were more than likely dwarfed by the imports from England and elsewhere, but there were still some notable quantities and acreage. Also, I think it is safe to assume given some of the comments above that much of it was used in commercial Irish brewing.

Why mentions of hop growing in this country appear to have become rare towards the end of the century I am not sure – it is quite possible that I just have not come across the Dublin Society reports. It is also possible - or perhaps probable - that it was either not commercially viable to grow them here year-on-year or that there were a number of poor seasons that affected the crop and disillusioned the farmers. It is certainly something I will revisit in the future but for now we will see what changes there are in reports and actually growing of hops in the 19th century Ireland.

1801 - There is a mention of duty to be paid on importation of hops from Ireland into Great Britain in Steel's Tables of the British Custom and Excise Duties published in that year and also in a Parliamentary register the previous year which would lead us to believe there was still some hop growing in the country, or at least the potential to do so.

1801 - A Mr. R. Smyth wrote to the Dublin Society regarding his espalier-trained hops that he was growing on half a rood (one eight of an acre) of his father's land in Kells Co. Meath, which he used in his own ale - via Transactions of the Dublin Society, Volume 2, Part 1 1801

1806 - A London newspaper reports that a duty of two-pence halfpenny per pound weight was resolved to be imposed on Irish hops by a committee in the House of Commons in England, it was passed a couple of weeks later. There are many other mentions of this bill too which again would make you think there was some trade between Ireland and Britain in hops, unless they were just covering themselves in case there was a resurgence in the growing of same on this island.

1816 - The Dublin Society were offering a premium of 1 shilling per barrel for beer brewed with Irish hops for private use or sale.

1833 - A John Pendergast from Inistioge in Kilkenny wrote to an English paper putting forth the idea of the landed gentry starting hop farms in Ireland to give more work to those living on their estates and to free said gentry 'from the enormous dead weight the heretofore has existed upon their well-known beneficence.' (!) It was reprinted a Dublin newspaper where the editor poured scorn on the idea that the gentry of Ireland would be interested in such a plan. Mr. Pendergast also suggested that an Irish acre would produce 26 hundred-weight of hops at 7 pound 12 shillings per hundred-weight. In response to the above letter, 'a Kent Radical' responded to say that there is an act of parliament which prohibits any one in Ireland from owning a hop farm larger than a quarter or perhaps half an acre. I cannot find any such legislation but maybe it is hidden somewhere I cannot access, or is combined into some much older act I am unaware of that prevented Catholics from owning any more land for crops that was necessary to feed themselves?

1835 - Under the headline ‘Irish Hops’ a Belfast newspaper states that The Commission of Revenue Inquiry recommended that Irish grown hops should pay a similar rate of duty as those grown in England. (There are also mentions of duties on ‘Irish hops’ in 1843, 1845 and 1846 in various parliamentary records.) Once again this would indicate that hops were possibly still being grown somewhere on the island, and in enough quantities to warrant discussion in parliament.

1835 - A Martin Doyle writing in The Roscommon & Leitrim Gazette, and other publications, on hop growing and the use of iron rods 'to attract the electric fluid' from passing thunderclouds as a way of combatting pests and diseases states that 'Hops grow freely in most of the southern counties in Ireland, are tithe-free, and exempt from duty.'

1849 - A report in an Irish newspaper in April via The Globe of the vessel ‘Erin's Queen’ arriving in London from Belfast with 18 packets of hops. Is this the first export of Irish hops to England? Probably not but it is the first record I can find. It would certainly have been going against the flow of hops coming the opposite direction so it would seem to be a noteworthy occurrence.

1849 - An English newspaper report of ‘The Citizen’ arrived in the Thames in May from Dublin with 27 (20 quoted elsewhere) pockets of hops from Ireland, which it appears was – unsurprisingly - not a common occurrence.

1849 - A Mr. Samuel Burke of Thomastown, Kilrush in Co. Clare sowed and acre and a half of hops. It was said to be a novelty 'in that part of the country.’

1849 - An English newspaper carries a mention under the title 'Irish Hops' of a vessel arriving in the Thames from Belfast in October carrying 5 pockets of hops that states that they are 'the produce of Ireland' and that 'this is the first arrival of this article from the sister country' - but as we saw above there were slightly earlier shipments.

1849 - A mention in a London newspaper in December of bales of hops arriving into England 'some time since' from an Irish port and that this was 'of some interest' and that there had been a further arrival of several bales on a ship called the ‘Cannaught[sic] Ranger’ from Sligo and Derry, and this was the 'second importation of the kind from the sister country' which again may be a little off the mark.

1850 - The vessel ‘Ranger’ arrived in London from Belfast, Dublin and Waterford in February and 'brought some packages of hops, as a portion of her cargo from the Irish metropolis, the produce of that country.’

1850 - A small note in an English newspaper in March that states - 'Irish Hops. Several additional importations of hops from Ireland have recently been noted. Hitherto the largest import has been eleven bales' so again we can see errors in reporting based on what was mentioned above. A sign that we need to be wary of what is reported in newspapers ...

1850 - Under the title 'Irish Hops' in an English newspaper in August, 17 packages arrived in London from Ireland.

Just a note on all these shipments. Although there are numerous mentions of these being Irish produced hops the doubting part of my brain thinks that maybe there were imported from elsewhere and passed off as Irish hops for financial reasons? I have no proof of this of course, but I think it may be worth considering, however unlikely it may be. For now, I am taking it at face value that hops were being grown in Ireland and exported to England for use by breweries in that country – an interesting and I would image surprising turn of event to many readers.

1852 - A reference in the proceedings of the now ‘Royal’ Dublin Society regarding an exhibition mentions a donation of a ‘specimen of Irish-grown hops’ donated by a John L. Tute of Blackrock amongst other agricultural specimens.

1855 - A newspaper mention that an experiment to grow hops in Ballyteigue, Wexford by a John Stafford was successful - the reporter sounded quite surprised!

1855 - The Irish Farmers’ Gazette states that ‘Hops in favourable seasons and favourable sites, dry and rich, come to much perfection in Ireland and may be gathered and cured tolerably well,’ but goes on to say that growing them on a commercial scale has been rare here.

1865 - 'Hop Growing at Kingstown [Dún Laoghaire] - A fine specimen of this useful creeper may now be seen in front of the residence of Captain Wilcox, Royal Terrace. It is very strange that hops are not more generally nurtured in Ireland' according to the Catholic Telegraph newspaper.

1867 - Thomas Bromwich a hop grower at Temple Farm near Alton in Hampshire was advertising hop plants for sale in an Irish paper under the headline, 'Hops, Hops, for Ireland.'

1867 - A newspaper mentions a successful attempt was made to grow hops in Ireland with the hope that there might be a larger scale experiment in the near future. No further information is given.

1872-1873 - A chart published in Thom's Directory of Ireland shows no acreage for hops in these years. Similar charts towards the end of the 19th century show similar results, although there is no way of being 100% positive that the information was being recorded correctly. It also possible, and probable, that it was on such a small scale - perhaps just for a breweries own use - that it would be unregistered.

Pre 1900? - There is a reference to hops being grown extensively on Whiddy Island in Cork in the schools' collection on the Dúchas website but no dates unfortunately so I am assuming the period to be in the 19th century given the tone of the mention.

So this was perhaps an unexciting century for Irish hops, and towards the end it appears that we had forgotten that we grew them here at all! Once again the middle part of the century is the most interesting, as attested to by those shipments of Irish hops to England. It would be nice to think that those were used in English ales – and I presume they probably were. I wonder is there any records in London or elsewhere of ale brewed with Irish hops? Somehow I doubt it…

As you can see there is quite a bit of conjecture and assumption based on the various newspaper reports, so as ever we need to be wary regarding what we read into those articles. Having said that there are certainly enough mentions to suggest a continuity of hop growing in the country even if it appears to dwindle at times to just sparse comments.

Still, at least we appear to have been a hop exporting country – however briefly – at one time. 

Next, we will look at the 20th century with a nod to the current one too. We will see plans – both big and small - to set up hop farms either side of this country’s independence before we hit the most productive decades of commercial hop-growing in Ireland – or at least recorded hop-growing – where I can quote varieties grown, acreage, yield and even alpha acid content with a certain degree of accuracy from the hop-growing co-op of a sort that existed in Kilkenny for almost 40th years.

But first let us go back to the start of the 1900s and some reported endeavours to start a hop industry in the country, or at the very least a hop-garden or two...

1906 - A reader called 'Fidelis' from Graiguenamanagh wrote to the editor of The New Ross Standard, intent on trying to start a hop garden and looking for advice. He also felt that any farmers living near a country town should plant a hop field as 'there are plenty of poor people who would find the work of picking the hops a pleasant change in their yearly life' - I am unsure if he received any replies or whether any ‘poor people’ took up his offer…

However, a follow-up letter appeared the next month in which Fidelis talks about a trip to England to his cousin’s farm and a discussion with hop brokers in London, where they tell him that soil is not the issue when growing hops but 'the atmosphere in which they are grown.' He says that they have not yet been tried in Ireland, which we now know is not true of course. But he then mentions that his cousin has 'grubbed up all the hops on his farm' as they were too labour intensive, and the price varied too much - but even knowing this the author still wants to pursue the idea of Irish hops further. (He also mentions, as an aside, that the 'Irish Militia regiments prefer the beer they are accustomed to, and there is now a large trade in Waterford and Kilkenny beer with Plymouth and Portsmouth.')

1908 - In an article in a Kilkenny newspaper the following sentence appears, which I am sure many would agree with over all of the centuries of hop growing. 'Hops can, no doubt, be grown in Ireland, but the enthusiast who should endeavour to make hop-growing a staple Irish industry would not be long in finding his way to the nearest lunatic asylum.' This is a reaction to a report that they were unprofitable even in England at this time and that imports into that country were affecting the price of the crop, although there is also a comment about the lack of much-needed sunshine in Ireland.

1909 - An article ran in The Dublin Evening Telegraph wondering why hops were not being grown in Ireland and interviewed a Mr. R. Grant of 46 Bessborough Avenue, North Strand, Dublin who was growing hops, but not it seems on a commercial scale. He comments on their history and requirements but does say they are 'profitable but at the same time a troublesome crop. No crop is more affected by the weather, nor more subject to destruction from blight, or attacks of insects. The profits on the other hand, in some cases have amounted to £100 per acre, and the average value of hop lands has been estimated at about £10 per acre.’

1911 - Taken from The London Standard, an article in the Donegal Independent about a 'novel German invasion' of Ireland where a German-American 'nobleman' called Baron von Horst - a 'well known Californian magnate' who was allegedly one of the biggest hop growers in America, had purchased 200 acres of land in Ireland - near Limerick seemingly - with the intention of starting a large hop farm here, and had contracted 1,100 German workman to assist him in his endeavour! He proposed that the Germans would teach the locals how to grow hops and that he had even selected three varieties he deemed suitable for the climate - sadly they are not listed by name but an additional part to the vision of Baron von Horst printed in a different newspaper says of the varieties selected, 'These are male grafts from the vines in Northern New York State in America and from the famous hop-fields of Bohemia joined with female roots specially selected form his fields in California. This combination the baron is convinced will ultimately produce superior vines and a characteristic product which will be known, in spite of the alien nature of its introduction, as "Irish hops"'. So, it sounds like he had already bred a hop variety from this parentage, which he assumed would grow well here.

1913 - The Limerick Industrial Association announced in The Freeman’s Journal that they were getting a free consignment of hop roots from Baron von Horst for farmers to trial. This whole endeavour warrants separate research and investigation.

1914 - A slightly bizarre advertisement appears in an English newspaper for 'A man capable of growing hops, to undertake growing hops in Ireland. Must be an Irishman.'

1914 - Back in Ireland the farming section of The Weekly Freeman's Journal raises doubt on the ability to ripen hop cones successfully in this climate and states that it is quite a technical crop regarding setting poles and pest control, and that it would require special training. It then states that there is no market for home-grown hops, as brewers will only place orders where they can be sure of a certain quantity and quality – a fair comment I would say. The writer of the article states that they 'do not recommend you to attempt hop growing on a business scale.’

1932 - An amateur hop grower with 30 years’ experience named Robert Ginn from Castlelyons in east Cork wrote into The Cork Examiner suggesting that we should start (or restart as we have seen) a hop industry here. He claims that his hops are as good or better than those grown in Kent and he had always had abundant crops.

1933 - An article in The Irish Press states that the Department of Agriculture were looking at the possibility of growing hops in 'suitable locations' such as Cork, Killarney, and Dublin. There were hops growing in the garden of a Mr. T. J. Geary in Sutton, Dublin and at the Botanic Gardens where the Keeper stated they 'grew splendidly' and he knew of no reason they could not be grown commercially here.

1930s - An experimental but unsuccessful attempt was made to grow hops in Ireland according to a 1963 newspaper article with no references – this may be related to the above mention in 1933.

1955 – It is reported in The Portadown Times that wild hops are growing wild in county Armagh and that a plant was found growing a few years previously in Drumnakelly and other areas.

1962 - Experiment carried out by An Foras Talúntais (the then agricultural development authority) into hop growing in Ireland at Dungarvan yielded 84 hundred-weight of dried hops - which is roughly 4,200 kg - worth £29 per hundred-weight. Yields grossed £580 per acre and expenses were heavy. It cost £600 per acre to establish the crop and it was susceptible to bad weather, pests, virus, and mildew - the 1961 crop was a total loss - but they were committed to assessing where might be suitable or better suited in the country.

1963 - Three experimental hop plots totalling 38 acres were planted in the spring of this year according to a 1966 report in The Irish Press. The variety chosen as seedless Fuggles as this was the variety that the previous year’s experiment showed most likely to succeed in this climate. Guinness paid more than they did for English hops because they were seedless but even paying that premium price they were still better value because of their higher humulone content.*

1964 - A notice appears in the Kilkenny People from the Chief Agricultural Officer that 'the first commercial hop gardens in Ireland have now been planted in Co. Kilkenny' and asking members of the public to let them know of any wild hop plants, which were known to be growing in the area, as they may carry pests or diseases.

1965 - According to the Kilkenny People, Edgar Calder-Potts of Highbank Farm in Cuffesgrange in Kilkenny was harvesting 22 acres of hops and hoped to increase it to 37 acres the following year. Harvesting took two weeks, and 11 women and 16 men were engaged in the work, although the hops were harvested by machine. There were also three other growers in the county. Cousins Stanley and Pat Mosse, and Captain A. Tupper of Lyrath, all growing for the Guinness brewery. Mr Calder Potts was expecting to pack 100 bags of one and a half hundredweight each. The first crop was in 1964 and both years’ harvests were of good quality according to the horticultural instructor Michael Power, who helped greatly with the project.

1966 - There was a total of 58 acres of hops between the four Kilkenny growers with a further 30 to be added in 1967 - initial expenditure was in the region of £1,500 per acre according to an article by Maurice Liston in The Irish Press. The poles were being supplied by the Forestry Department and the wire, anchor rods and other items apart from the machinery were being produced in this country. Quantity and quality compared favourably with English grown hops. Yield is reported here at 15 hundred-weight per acre and the return was £35 per hundred-weight. The varieties grown are still predominantly Fuggles with Northern Brewer only being introduced in this year. The Mosses had a new drying unit for the hops containing 20ft by 30ft kilns and a lot of investment had taken place into the industry in this area. A survey carried out by the Agricultural Institute had found more suitable sites in northern Kilkenny and there were indications - according to the article - that the project would further expand. This all appeared incredibly positive at this point and there was a huge amount of enthusiasm, work and commitment coming out of this newspaper report.

But in March of this year the head brewer in Guinness in Dublin decided that they should not use Fuggles in the brewery there after 1969 (they had actually stopped by 1967) saying ‘now that we hop on isohumulone the use of Fuggles is totally uneconomic’ which meant that the crop was instead being used by Irish Ale Breweries instead or sold to English breweries.* That would explain why there were 426 hundred-weight imported into England from Ireland – the first mention in the Barth report for Irish hops that I can find - some were perhaps used in Guinness’s Park Royal brewery.

Just a quick note here on the Barth reports that chronicle hop growing in Germany and around the world for over a hundred years. The finding of these, many of which are published in English, were a huge help with most of the facts and figures that follow here. You can take it that this is the source I use for the rest of this post unless I state otherwise.

1967 - It is reported that 794 hundred-weight of hops were imported into England from Ireland.

1968 - It is reported that this year 162 hundred-weight of hops were imported into England from Ireland

1969 - The Co. Wexford Federation of Rural Organisations discussed the concept of hop growing in the county but ‘investigation revealed that no future prospects in this field were envisaged, especially as trials were being conducted presently in Co. Kilkenny’ according to a local paper. There was no mention of the crop itself in the Barth report but 99 hundred-weight of hops were imported into England. 

1970 - The Barth report states that 119 acres of land were in hop production this year in Kilkenny, that strong winds damaged the crop, and that picking went from September the 4th to the 23rd, with the harvest being brought in by 3 machines. The quality was not as good as the previous year with 60% being Class I and 40% Class II and 988 hundred-weight were harvested. England imported 122 hundred-weight of Irish hops this year. (For reference 1 hundred-weight is approximately 50 kilograms.)

1971 - The Farmer’s Journal reports on the hop harvest under way in Kilkenny where Anthony Tupper grows 39 acres of hops in Lyrath. The article goes into some detail regarding the cost of setting up the hop production and ongoing expenses and points out that margins are very tight but at least expenses can be shared to a degree by adopting a co-operative system with like-minded individuals, which is what appear to have happened in Kilkenny.

The good weather that year had a favourable effect on the crop, especially the lack of strong winds. the harvest was 1,593 hundred-weight [I am not positive about this figure.] and the acreage increased slightly to 28 acres of Fuggles and 30 acres of WFB 135 (Northern Brewer), with Fuggles being gradually replaced. 43 hundred-weight of the crop was exported to England this year.

1972 - Poor weather and a lack of hop pickers hampered the harvest this year, but 55.7 tonnes (1,096 hundred-weight) of hops were brought in from a slight reduction of acreage to 138 acres, of which 62 acres were Fuggles and 76 acres were Northern Brewer as Fuggles was being replaced by ‘a better bittering hop.’ This ongoing change-out of variety was probably due to Guinness no long using Fuggles.

This year 23 hundred-weight were exported to England, and just for context 7,279 hundred-weight were exported from England to Ireland.

1973 - This was a good growing year with hardly any problems with pests or disease, but the crop was smaller than expected given the increased acreage. there were 67 acres of Fuggles and 77 acres of Northern Brewer – Bullion is also being introduced. No hops were exported to England this year. (A separate report states the areas as 60 acres for ‘Kilkenny Seedless Fuggle’, 91 acres for Northern Brewer and a half acre of Bullion.)**

1974 - A wet, windy and cold year meant that the crop was not as good as normal. The breakdown was 46 acres of Fuggles, 91 acres of Northern Brewer and 1 acre of Bullion – 61 tonnes were harvested. (The mention of any imports into England whatsoever finished up around this time, also the report changed to tonnes from this year onwards, so I have used that figure, but I have converted the areas to acres instead of the published hectares.) According to the Regional Horticultural Officer’s report for this year, that wind flattened a 13 acre garden at Mosse’s but the quality of hops was exceptionally good despite the weather issues, although curiously the alpha acids this year were 4.4 for Fuggles, the lowest since measurement began in 1966 with the highest being 6.3 in 1973, and 7.2 for Northern Brewer which recorded 10.3 in 1969.**

The 1974 crop report states that aphids, powdery mildew, and downy mildew were an issue this year along with the inclement weather. Northern Brewer is proving difficult and expensive to grow due to its susceptibility to wind damage, pests and diseases, but the trials of Bullion were proving satisfactory so far as a replacement. Wye Northdown, Wye Challenger, Record and S1478 – a Danish variety - were also being trialed this year.**

1975 - A hot summer this year had a negative effect on the yield although the report also says that the harvest was 69.6 tonnes, which was more than what was reported the previous year so it is possible that some of these figures may be a little off. The alpha content was higher than the previous year. The area in production dropped to 128 acres – 38 acres for Fuggles, 89 acres for Northern Brewer and 1 acre for Bullion. Northdown hops were also being introduced this year.

A report in the Irish Press says that Ireland’s hop farmers could get grants of £10,000 from the E.E.C. and that ‘they have now been invited by the Department of Agriculture to make their applications for this unexpected aid.’ Although according to the Barth report of this year, income supplements were paid in 1973 and 1974 too.

1976 - Another dry summer had a detrimental effect on the crop and the yield was down 13% to 61 tonnes although the alpha content was above average. Hops are still only being grown in Kilkenny according to the Barth report, on 156 acres – 39 ½ acres of Fuggles, 114 acres Northern Brewer, ½ acre of Bullion and 2 acres Northdown.

1977 - A relatively good year weather-wise saw the crop increase by 30% on the previous year, although the lack of sunshine meant the alpha acids were a little low, particularly in Bullion and Fuggles. 7 extra acres of Northern Brewer were planted increasing the total are to 163 acres which yielded 84 tonnes.

1978 - An outstanding year for the quality of the hops although the yield was down 13.5% to 72.5 tonnes. With the alpha on Bullion and Northdown matching the English ones and Fuggles and Northern brewer substantially higher.

1979 - 146 acres were in cultivation, with the area given to Fuggles and Northern Brewer reduced slightly. Picking was delayed due to weather issues, but the yield was back up to 82 tonnes. Alpha acids were 10 % lower than the previous years, apart from Northdown. The entire crop is still being taken by Guinness, although presumably the Fuggles were still not being used in Guinness stout.

1980 - After a cool and wet summer picking had to be delayed by a week to help with ripening. 75 ½ tonnes were harvested and judged to be Class I. The alpha values were 12% above the previous year in all varieties apart from Bullion. The hop acreage was enlarged back to 163 acres with increases space for Northdown and Northern Brewer so that the Kilkenny growers now had 29 acres of Fuggles, 118 acres of Northern Brewer, 15 ½ acres of Northdown and a tiny ½ acre of Bullion.

1981 - 178 acres in cultivation yielding 76.9 tonnes. (The report also says that there was 185 acres yielding 76.5 tonnes in 1980, which contradicts the information in last year’s report.) From this point there are no reports on hop growing in Ireland in the Barth report apart from two figures for acreage and yield, this went on for more than a decade.

Here they are …

1982 - 185 acres and 75 tonnes.

1983 - 188 acres. and 109.7 tonnes

1984 - 188 acres 109.7 tonnes again – not likely to match exactly the previous year so I suspect it is an error

1985 - 178 acres and 86.5 tonnes

1986 - 84 acres and 17.2 tonnes

1987 - 84 acres and 43.3 tonnes

1988 - 54 acres and 28 tonnes

1989 - 54 acres and 25.6 tonnes

1990 - 42 acres and 34 tonnes

1991 - 30 acres and 17.9 tonnes

1992 - 30 acres and 20.8 tonnes

1993 - 32 acres and 19 tonnes

1994 - 30 acres and 16.5 tonnes, and this year we get a brief report to say that there is just one hop grower left in Ireland and just one variety – Northdown, and it was to get worse …

1995 - 15 acres and 10.3 tonnes

1996 - 15 acres and 8.3 tonnes. (Lett's of Enniscorthy claim in a local newspaper that the Wexford Cream ale they were brewing at Greene King in Norfolk was 'made with Irish hops and Irish malt.’ – if true this surely must be Kilkenny hops?)

1997 - 15 acres and 8.8 tonnes, the report now shows the alpha content for the Northdowns, this year it was 10%

1998 - 15 acres and 9.5 tonnes - alpha 10.6%

1999 - 15 acres and 8.4 tonnes - alpha 9.2%

2000 - 7.5 acres and 2.7 tonnes - 11% alpha. There was a note regarding subsidies available of €3,360 this year.

2001 - 7.5 acres and 2.4 tonnes - 11% alpha. Subsidies dropped to €1,104

2002 – In one last, almost poignant, footnote the Barth hop report tells us:

‘Hops were grown in Ireland until 2001, latterly on an area of only 3 ha. As of 2002 production has ceased.’

And that was it, the end of a great idea that appears to have been professionally executed and was doing relatively well for a time, and I would imagine those reported issues with yield, damage and varying quality were similar to other countries – and better than some. But from a peak of 188 acres, 4 hop varieties and 110 tonnes in 1984 the Kilkenny hop production - our Irish hop production - dropped like a stone in a little over a decade and a half to just 7 ½ acres and 2.4 tonnes of Northdown at its sad demise in 2001. To analyse what happened would take a separate post, some interviews and delving deeper than I have done here. It was likely to do with a number of factors - mostly financial viability of course - but you can hear Simon Mosse that last grower speaking here about that hop growing period in Kilkenny in an interview from 2011.

The Calder-Potts family at Highbank are still connected with drink with their cider range and distilling amongst other enterprises - here is their website, and it does mention their hop growing.

Lyrath estate changed hands and became a hotel - it has a bar called 'Tupper's'...

So what happened next?

Well, the new breed of microbrewers were next to start growing hops, led by White Gypsy who were the first of the new batch of hop farmers and were followed by others including Wicklow Wolf, Canvas, Farmageddon and Ballykilcavan, and at one point Hop Social were using their community grown hops at Rascals in Dublin. I am not sure if all of these hop initiatives have survived the last couple of strange years, but perhaps this smaller more manageable way of doing things is the future of hop growing in Ireland on anything resembling a commercial scale?

Regardless of where we go from here, I have shown that we can – and did – grow hops in this country, although question marks remain over the commercial viability of the crops. What is very evident in all of this is how much we have forgotten of our hop-growing history – even those relatively recent forays into the industry. This is partially because regardless of the large-sounding acreage mentioned at times in these posts we really were operating on a tiny scale compared to other countries, but we did do it, and that is worth recording.

The other reason we have forgotten so much is because we are poor curators of our edible and drinkable history. Perhaps too many history writers prefer to wallow in the endless tragedy of death, revolution and oppression than look behind those tall walls of woe into how we lived, what we ate or drank, and what we grew on our small island? I am not entirely sure, but I would argue we could and should do both …

So perhaps we peaked too early in our endeavours to be self-sufficient hop growers, or maybe we could not achieve the acreage needed for profitability, or the climate was unsuitable, or it could be that our timing was poor ... or were we just not good enough at growing this tricky crop? Although I do not believe that this was the case – we have growers in this country…

Regardless, I would love to be able to wander through acres and acres of tall hop fields on a warm, late summer evening, past pretty modern-takes on oast houses, sipping a beer and rolling nearly-ripe cones between my fingers, the delicate smell of hops in the air and the last of the summer swallows flitting between the hop bines…

But then again, in certain ways I am much more of a romantic than a realist …

Thanks for reading.

Liam K.

P.S. I have purposely omitted the actual sources of exact newspaper mentions as there are quite a few and it was pain-staking research, but if anyone needs them, please email or DM me and I will send you on the details.

The Barth reports are here, I could not find many of them in English without manipulating the address. Contact me if you have any problems finding what you need.

That Dublin Society book from 1733 can be found here, the first image in this article is from this publication.

* Guinness and Hops by J.F. Brown

** Various crop reports kindly shared with me by ShaneSmith on Twitter

(All written content and the research involved in publishing it here is my own unless otherwise stated and cannot be reproduced elsewhere without permission, full credit to its source and a link back to this post.)

Newspaper image © The British Library Board - All rights reserved. With thanks to The British Newspaper Archive (www.britishnewspaperarchive.co.uk from whom I have received permission to display it here). The image below is from the hop fields in Highbank from the Irish Press from September 14th 1966 and is via my local library.

Wednesday, 14 September 2022

Irish Pub History: "Women's Houses"

On Thursday the 12th of May 1898 The Kilrush Herald and Kilkee Gazette carried the following few lines:

WOMEN'S PUBLIC-HOUSES

Father O'Leary, for nineteen years chaplain of Cork Prison, giving evidence before the Royal Commission on the Licensing Laws, stated that one of the worst aspects of the drink evil was that women, especially married women, obtained drink to a shocking extent in public-houses which were known as "women's houses." Batches of women might be seen on Monday mornings and Saturday some with babies in their arms and others leading little children by the hand. These sat about on the benches or stood at the bars, many in a state of intoxication, while their homes were neglected and their older children allowed to roam the streets without control.

I came across these “Women’s Houses” while researching the ‘Small-Pint’, and undersized pint measure akin to the ‘Medium’ or ‘Meejum’ measure, a subject I have already written about in a previous post. A column on Ireland’s licensing laws in The Enniscorthy Guardian on Saturday the 7th of October 1899 mentions that in Cork city ‘some publicans give the “small pint,” a pint with a very little poured out for 1½d, instead of 2d, to attract the women.’ The focus of the article was the prevalence of drunkenness in the Ireland in general and Father O’Leary is quoted here too with almost the same words, and with that intriguing “Women’s Houses” mention again.

With some further research I found an longer version of the evidence given by Father O’Leary on the 5th of May 1898 in The Dublin Daily Nation, which expands on his words and comments and mentions that as well as being a chaplain he is was president of the local branch of the Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children. His comments quoted above are part of larger report on the excessive use of alcohol by both men, women, and even children in Ireland at this time. This article does expand on what he says regarding women and drink, which I will not dwell upon here in case those reading this think I am attempting to paint women in a poor light! For a degree of balance, he does point out the issues with inebriated husbands and also with the publicans who served drunken people. (If you want to read the full article and be incensed for whatever reason then it is available via newspaper archive sources.)

Unfortunately, my digging did not turn up much more about “Women’s Houses” in Ireland to see if they were just frequented by women, which I find unlikely, or whether they were just more known to be more accommodating or ‘tolerant’ to women and children and therefore used more by women as a result. Perhaps it was more to do with serving that small-pint. That is if these places existed at all of course – although on balance I think that they did in some form. (I did find a mention of one in Liverpool and a vague mention of similar places in Germany.)

Related to this was a piece I found in The Freeman's Journal on Thursday the 25th of March 1909 on ‘Women and Children in Public Houses’ regarding a report to the House of Commons that showed the results of observations by the police on how many women and children frequented public houses over a two-week period – but annoyingly, unfairly, and exasperatingly does not mention the proportion of men by comparison!

Anyhow, here were their observations:

Belfast – 22 houses: 5,963 women and 6,449 children

Cork – 10 houses: 1,995 women and 2,233 children

Dublin – 22 houses: 46,574 women and 27,999 children

Limerick – 6 houses: 6,495 women and 4,583 children

Derry – 8 houses: 856 women and 975 children

Waterford – 6 houses: 5,441 women and 2,705 children

Some of the establishments were in fact spirit-grocers not just drinking ‘pubs’ as such, where - in Limerick for example - it was reported that women ‘got half drunk in public houses under the pretence of purchasing groceries, then go home and send boys or girls to the public house for more liquor to complete the debauch.’ In Waterford ‘the practice [of drinking in a public house] is principally confined to the very poorest class of women, and to public houses where women are the licensed persons and conduct the business. In such houses there is a “snug” set apart for them, which place is often full of half drunken women with children. It is amongst women whose homes and daily lives are squalid and filthy that this custom prevails.’

The disparity between Belfast and Dublin was put down to the scarcity of grocery shops in Dublin that did not also sell drink compared to Belfast – implying more temptation I take it(?) - and the somewhat bizarre statement that there may not be ‘so much porter-drinking amongst women in Belfast as in Dublin.’ (Were women in Dublin addicted to porter? I can attest from newspaper reports around, before and after this era they certainly drank it – even in pints, although they were to be denied that - in certain pubs at least - decades later.) The number of tenement house is also listed as a likely cause for the difference in numbers – so I presume class and living conditions were being given as reasons too. Also, in general there are more spirit-grocers in Belfast - as well as those aforementioned 'ordinary' grocers - so drinkers are more widespread even though the same number of houses were being observed in both cities. I am assuming that by this period The Children's Act of 1908, which was supposed to stop children from entering public houses amongst other regulations had not quite kicked in, so these figures may reflect that – or may not. It is also worth mentioning again those spirit grocers that sold both provisions and drinks, as well as purely drinking establishments and it was possibly and probably easier for certain people to get drinks in the former than the latter.

So, what started with a curious mention about those “Women’s Houses” ended with me finding information on women and public houses in the period either side of 1900. I am not entirely sure we learned much from the content itself, as it is contradictory at time, biased perhaps, and also missing more detailed information.

What we can say is that women went to ‘pubs’ of some description during this period – something that I think certain people doubt, as there is a general belief among some that women were not allowed into any sort of drinking establishment up until the 1960s or much later. Indeed, there are quite a few general news sources that state this or something similar without giving a timeline or expanding on the subject – mostly written by those repeating other sources and perhaps conflating it with the fact that certain bars would not serve a woman a pint of beer at certain periods in our history. I know beer and pub historians are not saying this but more general reports on our social history and certain news sites do state or at least imply it.

Now is probably a good moment to emphasise that of course there were places that excluded women, limited what they were served - if they were allowed in - and where they could sit, and that is just for starters. I don not think anyone can dispute that but it is certainly not so black and white that it can be dealt with in a single almost throwaway sentence in an article on our pub history and the role played by women in that history. If nothing else it is unhelpful to creating a discussion and understanding of what and how this happened.

Not all women did go to public houses of course, as there were differences in class, environs, location, means, and a host of other factors. We could perhaps argue that upper classes of both sexes drank at home or in hotels or pubs; the middle class may have drunk at home, with perhaps the man of the house heading to certain public house and certain rooms in those establishments; the lower-classes of both genders - and their children it seems - went to the pub. I am sure they did so to escape their drudgery, hated life, and living space – but even that would be too much of a generalisation without adding a timeline because it is era-based too. So, this may be the case in this period we are focussed on but may not reflect what was happening in the decades before or after this period.  The same is true as to why men frequented pubs of course, there are no right or wrong answers, as there were a multitude of reasons depended on the person, their circumstances and where they lived. It could be to get drunk, for companionship, for warmth, for news – for a host of reasons, both similar to why women drank and also radically different. It is worth saying here to that there are good and bad people in both sexes, and both struggle with alcohol dependency – and that there are good and bad parents too. Some things are sadly universal.

There are plenty of mentions of women – and men of course – in pubs in legal cases during the period I mention above and on through the following decades too, so when did this exclusion of women start? Certainly the change in licensing laws and the eventual demise of the spirit-grocer had an effect but did they exclude themselves to a degree to distance themselves from their drunken parents or from lower classes, or was it purely the predominantly male-ruled society driving this? I suspect that was some of it as well as a host of other factors, and the era exclusion appears to be at its worst is in the 1920s to the 1940s, and then it hung on in certain establishments in one form or another until the 1980s and later in some cases. There was misogyny, stupidity, and unfairness of course but it was not always the case all of the time – it is much more complicated than that and beyond my ability and knowledge to pursue further right here right now. What would be really worth exploring is why women went to pubs in the period mentioned above – why those “Women’s Houses” existed – even if some of the reasons are probably quite obvious. With some luck beer historian Braciatrix might cover parts of this to some extent in her upcoming book on Irish brewing history.

Clearly there was exclusion and misogyny in certain pubs up to relatively recently (and it still exists to a lesser degree) – but how widespread it was in the past - and that past needs to be broken down - I do not know, apart from anecdotal evidence, although we do know without doubt that it existed.

We seem to live in an age of absolutes, of black and white, and right or wrong. We lack nuance and ignore grey areas, and - as I have mentioned before - seem to shun words and phrases such as some ‘maybe’ and ‘perhaps’, and ‘not every’ and ‘I don’t know’. We need to promote more discussion based on facts and figures and discourage divisive vitriol aimed at inciting negative unhelpful sentiments, and not just on this trick topic but on a host of other subjects too.

And I would love to know more about those ‘Women’s Houses’ although I cannot help but think their existence spawned a whole gamut of stories we will never hear, of tragic tales and poignant social histories …

Liam K.

All written content and the research involved in publishing it here is my own unless otherwise stated and cannot be reproduced elsewhere without permission, full credit to its sources, and a link back to this post. Newspaper image © The British Library Board - All rights reserved. With thanks to The British Newspaper Archive (www.britishnewspaperarchive.co.uk) from whom I have received permission to display this image on this site.

Tuesday, 30 August 2022

Irish Brewing History: Black Water - Cork's 'Great' Porter Flood

On Thursday the 5th of December 1850, just as the workers in the Beamish & Crawford brewery in Cork city were taking their morning break and they heard what sounded like an explosion followed by a roar and a crash that shook the whole building. It brought everyone to their feet and heading in the direction of the sound, where they soon found the source. A huge vat containing porter had burst, its steel bands having given way and sending a torrent of porter through the vat room that carried everything in its path, including knocking down a substantial wall on one side of the structure. As if this calamity was not enough, the force of the deluge of porter had also damaged a jigger, a machine for pumping out the vast vats, which meant that porter was also now pouring from those in turn, which added to the wastage and damage.

Luckily the porter flowed out of the brewery towards the river Lee and not out towards the street or the rest of the brewery, which certainly helped to reduce the damage. Indeed, the workers themselves were extremely lucky to have been on their break or it is almost certain that there would have been serious casualties, or worse.

According to the more detailed reports the vat held 750 tierces* or 26,500 gallons (120,471 litres) of porter plus whatever was lost from the other vats, so possibly in excess of a quarter of a million pints of porter poured into the river, which would certainly have dyed a portion of it brown if not black. The value at the time was said to be £1,500 for the porter and £350 for the vat itself, so including the extra wastage it was probably £2,000 - a not inconsiderable sum at the time - and this did not take into account the clean up and the rebuilding of the fallen wall.

No doubt it would have made more news but for the lack of lives lost, although the story was carried by many newspapers on these islands as a small mention amongst the other calamities of the time.

To put the volume into perspective the great London porter flood at Meux & Co's Horse Shoe Brewery in 1814 released 128,000 gallons from the initial vat that burst, although more was released from other vats in the ensuing damage according to newspaper reports of the time. So Cork's version was perhaps one fifth of the volume of that main vat. Not a huge amount but still quite a considerable volume if it had flowed in the wrong direction, and unlike the London flood there was no loss of life.

The vat that burst in Beamish & Crawford was probably in the location I have shown here on the Goad fire insurance map of 1897, the vat room with a similar configuration is shown in the same location in a map from 1839 in Beamish & Crawford – The History of an Irish Brewery book. There was a quay right beside the river at that time so it is possible (but not definite) that it was the wall closest to the river which gave way, given that the porter seemed to escape damaging the rest of the brewery.

A quarter of a million pints flowing out into the Lee? It brings a whole new meaning to the term Running Porter …

Liam K.

(Here is the newspaper report from The Southern Reporter and Cork Commercial Courier on the 7th December 1850.)

*Tierce = 35 Imperial Gallons (42 Wine Gallons)

All written content and the research involved in publishing it here is my own unless otherwise stated and cannot be reproduced elsewhere without permission, full credit to its sources, and a link back to this post. Newspaper images © The British Library Board - All rights reserved. With thanks to The British Newspaper Archive (www.britishnewspaperarchive.co.uk) from whom I have received permission to display this images on this site. Goad Map via Wikimedia Commons


Friday, 8 July 2022

Tales from a Kilkenny Brewery #1: 'The Cavalcade of Loaded Drays' ...

Kilkenny has always been a city of events and fairs, which is a trend that has continued right to the present day with its hosting and support of the arts, comedy and food festivals. In the 1960s and 1970s it hosted a very successful beer festival which probably paved the way for all the other events that followed in the city, but if we go back to the 19th century it was famous for its fairs, where the emphasis was mostly on the serious business of the buying and selling of livestock more so than entertainment and experiences.

The Spring Fair held in March of 1858 was such an event, where the city was thronged for a weekend with people from all over the country and further afield for the purpose of trading in farmstock. It was purported to be the largest fair ever seen in the city by the reports of the day to the point that there were complaints about lack of space to be had for both people and animals, with the latter occupying every available free spot in the city. The hotels and other accommodation were packed to bursting and the city heaved with the movement of all those cattle, sheep, pigs, horses and of course people. One would imagine that the various sounds and smells, combined with the sights and general bustle of the city, made for a unique experience!

By Monday the trading was mostly done but the city would still have been crowded and full of activity as the logistical issue of getting the livestock from the seller to the buyer began. Huge amounts of cattle and sheep were being transported on that day by various methods including four special trains put on by The Great Southern and Western Company, with another having to be sent the following day such was the volume of animals in need of finding a way to their new owners.

On such a busy day it is probable that no one paid much attention at first to a drayman and his cart leaving Edmond Smithwick’s St. Francis Well Brewery and turning left on Parliament Street, as this would have been quite a common sight for the last couple of decades or so. But that drayman was quickly followed by another, and then another, and yet another until a column of drays and horses formed a slow-moving cavalcade that worked its way through the crowds of people and livestock as it headed down what was then King Street before turning left on to Rose Inn Street and jigging right on to John’s Bridge and over the fast-flowing Nore.*

By the time the procession had stopped emerging from the archway at the brewery it was an incredible fifty-three drays long. The size of each dray is not known but if we estimate they were possibly five metres long including horses and the rig itself, and allowing for another two metres or more between drays that makes almost 400 metres of a convoy of drays loaded with ale and porter. This would mean that as the first dray was going over the bridge the last one was only just exiting the brewery.

This is must have stopped people in their tracks – literally. The newspapers of the time states that ‘sensation caused by the passage of the vast cavalcade of loaded drays through the fair was great in the extreme.’ The use of those words - ‘sensation’, ‘vast’ and ‘extreme’ - give an inkling of what a sight it must have been to behold. (Note: I must admit to taking all of this with a small grain of salt, as it seems like a huge amount drays for a brewery to have, although they may have called in favours from other establishments. The reporter - quoted above - seems to imply it was all one delivery but of course the drays might have gone back to the brewery to be loaded again. How fifty-three drays, horse and drivers would even fit inside the walls of the brewery is another issue too ...)

This enormous quantity of ale and porter was destined for the export trade via the railway station at the eastern end of John Street, and specifically a train from The Waterford and Kilkenny Company who would bring the load (probably) to the docks in Waterford and from there onwards to other ports across the sea and thirsty palates in 'foreign' inns and taverns. It would appear from reports at the time that the stock had to leave that day regardless of the fair in order to make its sailing, as time and tide indeed do not wait for man - or brewery.

As to what beer was on those drays we do not know, but at the time the brewery was selling Pale Bitter Ale, XXX and XX ale and also XX Stout Porter. The load may have been mostly their stout porter as two English newspaper advertisements of the time carry advertisements for Smithwick’s Kilkenny Stout Porter, although the Kilkenny report mentions both ale and porter.**

I can find no record of how many barrels were sent but if we calculate that the drays could have held a double stack of perhaps 6 plus 4 to make 10 Irish barrels this would make 530 Irish barrels***, which in modern terms would be about 75,599 litres or 42,960 Imperial pints.**** Indeed the reporting of the day does say that the quantity sent was ‘immense’, so although there is a huge amount of guesswork here we could be looking at those sorts of figures – but be aware again there is no record of quantity.

(For context, Guinness were exporting 848 hogsheads of porter a week around this time and relatively smaller brewers like Watkins were sending 289 - a hogshead was roughly a barrel and a half in size.*****)

But by anyone’s measurement, that long line of drays and horses piled high with ale and porter must have been hugely impressive ...

Liam K.

(Adapted from a report in The Kilkenny Moderator on the 31st of March 1858)

*This is the route I assume it would have taken but it is not reported.

**The Worcestershire Chronicle on the 7th of April 1858 and The Gloucester Journal of the 22nd of May 1858

***This is at best an educated guess but I may not be very far off in my calculation, also I have seen images of drays with anything from two to perhaps twenty barrels stacked on them so this is an average guess. There is absolutely no proof of the quantity – THIS IS NOT FACT!

****I am assuming a barrel is an old Irish Barrel by liquid volume which would be 40 Irish gallons. An old Irish Gallon is 3.566 litres so an Irish Barrel contained 142.64 litres. FYI, tierces were slightly larger and dry volume barrels were also different.

***** The Waterford Mail - Tuesday 20th April 1858

All written content and the research involved in publishing it here is my own unless otherwise stated and cannot be reproduced elsewhere without permission, full credit to its sources, and a link back to this post. Newspaper image © The British Library Board - All rights reserved. With thanks to The British Newspaper Archive (www.britishnewspaperarchive.co.uk) from whom I have received permission to display this images on this site.

Tuesday, 28 June 2022

Ale Aboard? Beer Exports from Ireland in 1786

A new online archive resource has sprung to life of late in the shape of the Virtual Record Treasury of Ireland, which in its own words 're-imagines and reconstructs through digital technologies the Public Record Office of Ireland, a magnificent archive destroyed on June 30th, 1922, in the opening engagement of the Civil War.' This incredible undertaking has already thrown up plenty of lost history but of course what interests us here is any brewing mentions that may have been destroyed and are now rediscovered.

One entry that interested me was the list of exports from Ireland for the year ending the 25th March 1786. This document's creator is the Chief Remembrancer's Office but it is via the Central Bank Archives and it shows many products including foodstuffs that should be of interest to food historians. It makes fascinating reading in general, but of real use to us is a listing of the beers exported from Ireland in barrel quantities:

DestinationVia DublinVia BelfastVia NewryVia WaterfordVia SligoTotals
France104    104
Italy 10   10
Madeira*     24
Spain28    28
Streights#2010   30
Antigua16113435  330
Barbados 84   84
Carolina6653   119
Jamaica24    24
New England230    230
New Foundland   52 52
New York2618   44
Nova Scotia40    40
Pennsylvania14630  6182
Virginia74154   228
West Indies in General 96   96
Totals919589355261,625

* The total is in the tally at the end of the original document but I can not see it in the detail.
# Presumably Gibraltar

The total appear to be wrong in the tally at the end of the document where it says '1,705' but I have calculated it to be 1,625 as you can see (I may have missed something ...) - and there are also 22 barrels of 'ale' listed elsewhere, which were destined for the West Indies. There seemed to have been no exports from Cork this year, but that would change over the next few decades.

What was meant by the term 'Beer' could be up for argument, especially as ale was listed separately (albeit in a small quantity) but my assumption here is that it was a general term like we use today. The term possibly included porter and 'normal' hopped ale although probably mostly the former.

That is quite a list of destinations and it is certainly nice to see the written facts of an export trade in beer from Ireland in this way - although sadly no breweries are mentioned - but just to put it into context the same overall document shows us importing 54,515 (and a half) barrels of 'beer' from England in the same period!

It is quite possible that some of those exports shown above are actually beer that was originally brought in from England or Scotland, but we will gloss over that thought for now ...

Also fair play to whoever sent the 6 barrels of beer from Sligo to Pennsylvania!

Liam K.

This item originally belonged to the Dublin Chamber of Commerce and the Commercial Buildings Company, whose premises and assets the Bank purchased in 1963 to facilitate the building of the Dame Street tower. It is now in the archive of the Central Bank of Ireland. Here is the link to the document which is available for use under the Creative Commons 4.0 International License. (Header image via Virtual Record Treasury of Ireland)

All written content and the research involved in publishing it here is my own unless otherwise stated and cannot be reproduced elsewhere without permission, full credit to its source, and a link back to this post.

Friday, 24 June 2022

Beer Myths on Beer Mats? A Closer Look at the Legendary Marketing of Smithwick's and Kilkenny Ales

There are two much-captured street views in the extremely photogenic city of Kilkenny, one is the view up the steps on St. Mary’s Lane that frames the same-named church, while the other is down a cobblestone alley off Parliament Street that leads to a wide-doored archway over which are, in raised red lettering, the words, ‘E. Smithwick & Sons Limited.’ The other commonality between these two views is that both lead to places of worship of a sort for many pilgrims – or more accurately tourists these days - as St. Mary’s now houses the Medieval Mile Museum and the latter what was a world-famous brewery.

Both are of historic importance but the Smithwick's brewery - or the St. Francis Abbey Brewery to give it its proper name - is an establishment that I am mildly obsessed with for a number of reasons. It was the last of the great local (to me) breweries to close its doors; it was a huge employer for over the years to the people of Kilkenny; it was the originator of what is probably the first great Irish festival the Kilkenny Beer Festival in the 1960s, and as early as the 19th century its beers were celebrated beyond these shores and especially so in England. I could go on but suffice to say it brought wealth, pride, and recognition to the smallest city in Ireland and rightly deserves to be remembered, lauded and revered for the huge impact it left on Irish brewing history.

But is there a nagging issue, a grey murkiness that muddies its history, which means that the brewery has lost more than it has gained in the promotion of ‘Brand Smithwicks’ and becoming for the most part a single product within the portfolio of a much larger global company? This is a subject I have written and commented about before, both in a short history on brewing in Kilkenny and in a piece on the dubious history of Irish Red Ale, but I have never explored these legends one by one, so here I hope to do just that. I have picked three stories from Smithwick’s - and Kilkenny ale’s - marketing that come up in much of the advertising for these two brands, and which are used on their promotional material and advertisements.

Any history has its seeds of truth but unfortunately when marketing and monetary gain are added to the mix it can often lead to the blurring, inventing and erasing of history in order to create a marketable narrative, but is that the case with Smithwick’s and Kilkenny ales?

I will let you decide ...


Legend #1 - The Brewery was Founded on the site of St. Francis Abbey


Here is the back of an undated 'Kilkenny Irish Beer' beer mat where it says:

'Kilkenny Irish beer is brewed in the famous Smithwick’s Brewery. Founded in 1710 on the site of St. Francis’ Abbey, the brewery is set amidst the rolling green hills of Kilkenny. The special beer is made from only the finest natural ingredients and brewed to the highest of traditional standards.'

Ignoring that 1710 date for now plus the fact that the brewery was always in extremely urban surroundings with few if any 'rolling green hills' even visible from the site, we will focus on the admittedly loose implication that the brewery was founded on the actual site of the abbey building - an image that is often used with the Kilkenny brand, and a link that is used in the advertisements for Smithwick’s too. (Incidentally, as I have discussed previously in that article on red ales, Kilkenny beer was launched as a new beer in 1987 and was not available in Ireland until 1995 so its heritage has no real historical age. It was developed as a reaction to other Irish-touted beers in the late 1980s.)

The abbey building itself is not mentioned on the lease description from 1867, or when the site was sold in 1827 (both of these can be seen or accessed via that Kilkenny brewing history article), and in the 1868 Royal Society of Antiquaries of Ireland report concerning the condition of the tower it states that:

'The ruins of the Abbey including the tower were possessed by a person who had not the means of doing anything to preserve them. Although they adjoined the Brewery of the Messrs Smithwick, unfortunately they did not belong to those gentlemen - if they did, no subscription would have been thought of, for the work would have been done at once without assistance from any other source. The Messrs Smithwick had most liberally headed the subscription list with a donation of £10 ,and would afford any facility and assistance in their power.'

It was both magnanimous and logical that the Smithwick's family would assist in the upkeep and repair of the abbey but they clearly did not own it at this point.

Indeed the abbey building was up for sale in 1880 as can be seen in an advertisement in The Kilkenny Moderator on the 15th September 1880 which states:

CITY OF KILKENNY

AUCTION OF VALUABLE FREEHOLD PROPERTY AND FRUIT GARDEN.

MESSRS. McCREERY BROTHERS have received instructions from Mrs. Hayes to Sell by Public Auction. in one Lot, on WEDNESDAY. 22nd SEPTEMBER, 1880, At the City Court House, Kilkenny. at 12 o'clock, noon, Her Interest (Freehold) in the Dwelling House and Premiers, known as St. Francis' Abbey and Gardens. situate in the Parish of St. Mary's and City of Kilkenny (adjoining Messrs. Smithwick's Brewery). 

We can again see that it was adjoining and not part of the brewery at this point.

It is also worth quoting George Henry Bassett in The Kilkenny City and County Directory and Guide from 1884 states that:

'The Abbey itself with a very choice fruit garden and cottage was sold a few years ago for 600 to the late Mr. William Morrissey hardware merchant Mrs. Mary Morrissey his widow is now in possession.'

So although it was called ‘The St. Francis Abbey Brewery’ (which just followed on from the same named distillery) it was originally situated beside the abbey building but not part of it. There may have been a portion of it leased by the brewery of course but it certainly was not part of the property as such at this time, although the cooperage may have extended right up to the knave of the abbey as mentioned my George Measom in his guidebook in 1866 (More on this later). In other words the walls of the abbey building may have been used as the outer walls of some of the brewery structures.

The Kilkenny Moderator from Saturday 19th of May 1894 mentions some archaeologists visiting 'places of archaeological and antiquarian interest in the city, including St. Francis' Abbey, now [my emphasis] portion of the premises by the great Brewery establishment of Messrs. E. Smithwick & Sons' and in the same newspaper on the 6th of September 1902 in an article about the abbey it states that:

'The ruins of Francis Abbey, standing in an orchard the property of Mr. George Stallard, and adjoining the premises of the sell-known brewery, the property of Messrs E. Smithwick and sons, Ltd.'

Although three days previously they had printed the same article, but stating that the abbey was inside the Smithwick's property. Whether this was an error corrected by the later publication or not I do not know, or if it was around this time that the existing abbey structure finally came into the hands of the Smithwick's business. It certainly appears to be in the possession of the brewery by 1907 as when talking about the abbey in Journal of the Irish Memorials Association of that year a Colonel White states that 'it is now a store in Mr. Smithwick's Brewery.'

One of the best sources for Kilkenny history is the Irish Historic Town Atlas for the city, and one of its maps for c. 1842 (based on the OSI maps) clearly show a starch manufacturer abutting the walls of the abbey building, with the brewery itself to the south of that business. That enterprise may have been part of the general Smithwick's business – I am unsure – but it served a different purpose to brewing. My contention would be that the brewery spread north over the course of the 19th century and into the 20th to eventually take over the whole site to where the Breagh river meets the Nore, the footprint it had when the brewery closed in 2013.

For fairness and clarity I must point out that in ‘Kilkenny and its Vicinity’ published by Browne & Nolan in 1851 and writing about the condition of the abbey, and commenting on how it was now being used as a ball alley, says that 'parts of the building form a portion of Mr. Smithwick's Brewery establishment,' although my interpretation of that is as I have already stated, that some of the walls form the boundary of the property rather than them being within the site itself, indeed I came across a mention in the Historic Environment Viewer for the site of the brewery regarding the removing of a cooperage structure that they had built up against the abbey itself. Also for balance yet again, in The Builder Vol.36 from 1878 there is a mention of 'the ruins of St. Francis Abbey in Smithwick's brewery' but I believe this was just an assumption made by people getting a general tour of Kilkenny.

So was the brewery founded on the actual site of the existing abbey building? I can find no verifiable evidence that the abbey was in Smithwick's ownership or occupation until around 1900, although the term 'site of' is open to the interpretation of being somewhere close to the abbey itself (Even the distillery of Patrick Brennan that became the brewery is mentioned as being at St. Francis Abbey in 1824 - more on this below) but the implication in some of the marketing could be interpreted in a way that implies the extant abbey building has been part of the brewery for centuries. It is possible and indeed likely that the grounds of the original general abbey site - and the other buildings and land that no doubt existed around the building - may have become home to the brewery site, but that much-advertised building has no verifiable ancient historic connection to the brewing of any Smithwick's beer. If what is meant by some of the marketing is that the brewery was situated on the general abbey environs then that may indeed be accurate.

It is a grey area in some ways but crystal clear in others, depending on the interpretation of the narrative.


Legend #2 – That Smithwick’s ale was first brewed in 1710

There are round fish-eye discs attached to the front of many pubs - in Kilkenny anyhow - that proclaim:

SMITHWICK'S

First brewed in Kilkenny in 1710

Still enjoyed at [pub's name] in 2010

There are also beer mats that proudly state 'Superior Irish Ale since 1710' or sometimes something as definitive sounding as 'Over 300 years ago in 1710, John Smithwick began brewing his famous ale at the St. Francis Abbey Brewery.’ Some are slightly less blatant with the phrase 'crafted and perfected since 1710' but all of the marketing again suggests, or in most cases states, that the same Smithwick's ale that is available today has been brewed for over three centuries, practically stating that nothing has changed in those three centuries. Almost all advertisements, including recent ones on mainstream television, also appear to imply this to be a true fact.

But there are many issues with this assertion of course, and again we will side-step the 1710 founding date for now and look at something relatively more recent. Firstly, I will repeat here a paragraph from one of my own aforementioned red ale posts:

"A report on Smithwick’s ‘275th’ anniversary in The Kilkenny People in 1985, admittedly 20 years after the launch of its kegged ale states that ‘public taste […] for ale had begun to change and a demand for a darker, sweeter ale became apparent late in 1965. Smithwick’s draught keg was developed [my emphasis] therefore to meet demand.’ So this also seems to rule out the possibility that Smithwick's Draught was a rebrew of an older XX ale or similar from Smithwick's wonderful repertoire of ales from the 19th and early 20th century, more is the pity, and seems to show that they were indeed mimicking in a way, another kegged ale that was selling well at the time - [Watney's] Red Barrel."

The original article I quote clearly states that what we think of now as Smithwick's ale was created in 1965 - not 1710.

If we want further evidence we can look at what was their most popular beer prior to this period - Smithwick's No.1 - which was a pale ale and not a red ale, as attested to by adverts such as one in the New Ross Standard on the 20th August 1966 that clearly mentions 'its rich golden colour'. We can look back to older adverts which mention other beers too, such as one in the Kilkenny Journal and Leinster Commercial and Literary Advertiser on the 31st of January 1852 that champions a 'Pale Bitter Ale', and we can also mention 'XXX & Pale Ales' from the same publication on the 15th of January 1868. Very importantly we can quote the Kilkenny Moderator on the 12th of March 1828 and in what was one of the first mentions of beer production from the St. Francis Well Brewery mentions:

'Porter, Pale Butt, & Strong Ale, in Wood and Bottle, of their own brewing.'

These are for sale in Edmund and Patrick Smithwick’s shop on High Street in Kilkenny. None of these sound anything like the current offering that is Smithwick's Draught, and if you had a 'famous red ale' would you not be mentioning it in your own advertisements for your own beers? It cannot be the porter as that was dark, the pale butt beer was - well - pale, and the strong ale may have been amber or reddish but the current version of Smithwick's can hardly be classed as a strong ale by any definition of the term.

Also, in a report on a breach of the public spirit licence in The Kilkenny Moderator of 3rd of May 1862 'Smithwick's pale ale' is mentioned in the context that it was a common commodity, and the Waterford Mail from the 10th of September 1869 in another court report about some of those accused 'testing the strength of Smithwick's "pale butt".'

An article in The Waterford News and Star from September 1873 mentions a strong, aged amber ale but that certainly sounds nothing like modern day Smithwick's apart from the colour perhaps - I would think that this is the XXX mentioned above.

Admittedly other various adverts from the 19th century mention just ales or mild ales in general but none mention this 'famous' reddish coloured ale that Smithwick's claims to have brewed for centuries. Again, just for clarity and fairness an advertisement in The Cork Daily Herald on the 11th of February 1882 for a Cork agent for the brewery's beers list their East India Pale Ale as well as that XXX ale mentioned above, plus an XX and an X ale. All of these may have been darker than their pale ale and possibly amber in colour as described above but I have given my thoughts on amber ales previously and although they did exist it is a stretch to connect any of those beers with Smithwick’s modern 1960s' keg ale.

Most interestingly, George Measom in ‘The Official Illustrated Guide to the Great Southern & Western Railway’ mentions a visit to Edmond Smithwick’s brewery in 1866 and talks about the ale production there, noting that there were 'two enormous pale ale vaults' in which were stored '4,000 hogsheads of ale.' He also mentions the malting process within the brewery and how carefully it had to be dried 'to prevent the slightest tinge or colour being imparted to the malt...' (no other malt or roasted barley are mentioned) and also with regard to the boiling of the wort he states that the coppers are uncovered 'to preserve the colour of the wort, which would be darkened by higher pressure.'

Does any of this sound like anything even remotely red-tinged? It sounds like pale ale being brewed with pale malt and being store in a 'pale ale vault'. The brewery was of course also brewing porter at this time, which just gets a mention in the heading but not later on. India Pale Ale gets a mention as being 'extensively brewed' by them so I am assuming that porter was in relatively small quantities, as were any other ales.

In 1892 according to The Dublin Daily Express of the 16th of August the St. Francis Abbey Brewery showed a 'large quantity of East India pale ale' at The Distillers, Brewers and Allied Trades Exhibition in The Rotunda in Dublin, implying that this was their bestselling ale at the time perhaps? Indeed the were awarded a Diploma of Merit for that beer and it was deemed to be 'equal to some of the best of the English brands' according to a later report in The Kilkenny Moderator. If they were brewing a famous red ale would they not exhibit it here too?

Moving forward a few decades an advertisement in The Sligo Champion on the 10th of December 1965 states that the pale Smithwick's No 1 was being called "Ireland's legendary ale. The clearest call of true Irishmen for over two hundred years.' and has the by-line of 'Ireland's traditional ale' so how can this product, which is obviously not the same as the new kegged ale offering, be this alleged historic ale as well as the modern kegged brew? (Not that the new brew was being touted as such at its launch, that assertion came much later.) In my opinion it simply cannot, it is just that the marketing shifted from one beer to the next when No. 1 was side-lined, even if bottles of the modern branding currently have a rather cheeky 'No. 1' on its label!

When Smithwick’s briefly rebranded much of their ale to the ‘Time’ name there were advertisements that listed their produce and none sound like an old red ale recipe, in fact the whole Time rebrand was a modernisation of their beers and the closest sounding at a push – Extra Time – still does not sound like our modern Smithwick's ale. You can read more about that branding hiccup in my post on the subject.

Most damning is an advertisement that the company themselves took out in a magazine called Kilkenny '66 issued by the Kilkenny Junior Chamber. Although the ascertain that the brewery has been brewing for 'over 250 years', which will be dealt with next, they advertisement also clearly states that Smithwicks Draught is 'the new flavour in beer.' So the brewery themselves clearly saw it as a brand-new brew and not dating from 1710.

Finally, Michael Jackson in his Beer Companion book published in 1993 can tell us that Smithwick's was then brewed with 'highly modified pale ale malt, three percent roasted barley and 20 percent corn syrup' plus various hops. That certainly does not sound like a recipe that has been around since 1710, and although Jackson may have been wrong about certain facts on Irish brewing this seems to be too accurate a recipe not to have been acquired in or from the brewery itself. And in Iorwerth Griffiths' much read and appreciated Beer and Cider in Ireland published in 2007, he gives a recipe that he says may not be up to date, but the implication is that it was certainly the recipe at one time, which sounds quite like Jackson's and may be from the same source. The fact that they both mention roast barley as an addition to the brew is of interest as roasted barley, as distinct from roasted malted barley, was not to the best of my knowledge in use in the early- or mid-19th century and certainly not in 1710.

Even if we dismiss all of the above and we did consider the assertion that it is the same beer that was brewed when the brewery began, then by considering the changes that would have taken place in the brewing process, and the ingredients and the equipment, the only way any claim can be entertained that it is the same beer from centuries ago is to employ Trigger's reasoning from Only Fools & Horses regarding the broom he had all his working life. He just changed the head 17 times and put 14 new handles on it.

If you do that with a beer can it still be the same beer?


Legend #3 – That the Smithwick's brewery was established in 1710

Just about every advertisement, label and beermat makes this claim, the implication being that essentially the Smithwick’s family has being brewing in the same site for over 300 years. Many sources, which perhaps come from information from the brewery itself, mention the name of a Richard Cole as having a brewery on the site and that he was somehow connected with a John Smithwick who commenced brewing in 1706 or 1710 depending on the source.

This is a problematic assertion to prove in many ways, mostly caused by lack of available evidence, and a story regarding an almost hidden brewery - or owner - existing for over a century in plain sight in Kilkenny, which because of the Irish Penal Laws forbidding ownership of certain property by Catholics, had to be kept hush-hush ...

Let us look at what we do actually know about the brewery and its owners, for example Pigot's Trade Directory of 1824 does not list any Smithwick's as brewers and indeed mentions Patrick Brennan as a distiller at St. Francis Abbey. Although a Smithwick and O'Callaghan are shown as both grocers and wine merchants, so clearly Edmond Smithwick was not afraid to be known to be connected with a premises and business at this point in time. Quite the opposite in fact, as he was a well-known businessman, as was his father John before him. And no, that John is not the one who allegedly founded the brewery although some histories I have read seem to suggest he was, as they somehow lose a couple of generations of the family! This seems to be a problem with most of the purported history, both official and repeated - that these two Johns are conflated and we are somehow to ignore a whole generation of the Smithwick’s clan - namely the 'first' John's son and  the other John’s father – an enigmatic Peter Smithwick. Even if you look at a video from the Smithwick's Experience here, it shows various members of the family but seems to combine those Johns into one character. It would be wonderful to hear more about that Peter and how he influenced - or perhaps did not - his son to become a merchant and in turn influenced his grandson Edmond to build his brewery but I can find almost no information about him in any of the available brewery information, which is remarkable given that according to the alleged history of the brewery he would surely have inherited the 'secretive' business at one point.

More evidence of Edmond’s own business interests is shown in a notice of a partnership dissolution between the aforementioned Edmond Smithwick and Owen O'Callaghan in Finn's Leinster Journal on the 7th of July 1827 where he is shown to be a merchant dealing in 'grocery, wine, spirit, oil and colour, soap and candle' as well as a 'corn, flour, and boulting business'. O'Callaghan received the latter business and Edmond partnered with a Peter Smithwick (probably his brother who may have been named after his grandfather who I mention above?) on the former. So he was certainly a well-known business man and unafraid of having his name attached to these businesses prior to his involvement with the brewery, even before he went on to be a mayor of Kilkenny.

The advertisement from when the site where was up for lease is in my post on Kilkenny breweries as mentioned above, and the site is described as an 'Extensive Distillery, Malt House, Corn Stores, and Water Mill' which was 'now in full working order.' (Implying it is a relatively new reconstruction.) The advertisement says that the distillery could be converted into a brewery at zero cost, implying that it was not a brewery at that time. To make spirits in a distillery you need to make a ‘beer’ of sorts first so it would make perfect sense that it could be converted into a brewery as much of the equipment was the same.

So it appear by looking at these advertisements that Edmond Smithwick took over the lease of the distillery property in 1827, with beer production commencing some time after that and beer was certainly being produced by 1828 as per the advertisement mentioned above.

The Brennans still owned the actual site up to 1867 when it was in The Court of Chancery. And according to a petition in The Irish Law Times and Solicitors' Journal, Volume 1 of 1868 the site was due to be auctioned later that same year, as referenced in my Kilkenny article. So at this time the Smithwick’s family did not own the site, it was just leased to them. An interesting note on the petition states that the site was held in two leases, one dated from 1753 from William and Anne Archbold to an Ambrose Evans, and the other from 1780 by a Rev. George Evans to and Edward Evans. No mention of a Cole or Smithwick at those dates.

George Measom again in ‘The Official Illustrated Guide to the Great Southern & Western Railway’ states in the title of his description that the brewery was established in 1828, and it seems strange to me that the brewery would allow this date to be published if they knew it to be wrong. Indeed Measom would surely have had to ask someone when the brewery was established in order to get the date for his publication so why at this point did they not say 1710, as surely Edmond knew his own history?

By the way, that 1710 date seems only appear at the end of the 19th century, so perhaps that was when some paperwork was found mentioning some connection between a John Smithwick and Richard Cole and the fact that there was a brewery on Richard Cole's property, although this would have been common enough, as a brewhouse would have been a normal building to have on many farm properties or those attached to medium or large houses. The output would generally be consumed by the workers and those who lived in the house more so than for sale to the public.

There is an advertisement for the 275th anniversary for the brewery in The Kilkenny People on the 27th of September 1985 mentions Richard Cole living in Kilcreene Lodge (although he actually seems to have lived in Archer's Grove outside the city according to family biographies) and obtaining a 'fee farm grant' for the site that later became the brewery, although it is a little vague on the details and completely omits any evidence of brewing on the site until 1827. In the New Ross Standard 25 years earlier on the 18th of March 1960 the wording is equally vague in an article about that Time rebranding that was presumably given consent for publication by the brewery, where it states that 'The firm of Smithwicks was founded in 1710 by John Smithwick. At the same time, one Richard Cole, founded a brewery in Kilkenny. The two firms, Smithwicks and Coles, combined to be known as Smithwicks Brewery.' This hardly makes sense, as seemingly the brewery had to be kept secret according the current line of history touted by the marketing so how could it be known by that title? (Also, according to biographies Richard Cole was an army Colonel and later an M.P, there are no mentions of any other businesses.)

Tellingly, the aforementioned Historic Town Atlas for Kilkenny states clearly that 'Smithwicks, the best-known Kilkenny brewers, acquired Brennan's distillery in 1827 and established St Francis' Abbey Brewery', and this is a serious publication - the definitive guide to the history of Kilkenny. Not infallible of course but also rarely - if ever - wrong in my experience.

In the masterplan for the redevelopment of the brewery site on the Kilkenny County Council website the authors do mention that the 'first documented brewery in operation within the grounds of St Francis' Abbey has its origins at this time. In 1706 a fee-farm grant for what is now a part of the modern brewery property was leased to Richard Cole by the Duke of Ormond. Cole established a partnership with John Smithwick, who came to Kilkenny in 1710' although they then go on to say that there 'is little documentary evidence for this first brewery, though it appears to have been a small retail operation. Although apparently successful, the business did not remain in the Smithwick family after the death of John.' [All my emphasises] Firstly I certainly find it strange that in what is a very good history of the area around the brewery that there is a certain ambiguity, and that there is no references to the source of this information given it flags the source of almost every other fact, so unfortunately there is no corroborating evidence to these assertions. Secondly it is interesting to note that they say for a fact that the brewery fell out of the hands of John after his death. Personally, I find much of this very vague and I wonder were the authors being deliberately ambiguous in order to conform to the prescribed Kilkenny history of the brewery so as not to anger multiple parties. It is difficult to know …

Another source of knowledge on brewing in Kilkenny - Thomas Halpin - who is referenced in the HTA above wrote an article for the Old Kilkenny Review (I possess a physical copy) of 1989 and in it he mentions that a 'fee farm grant for what is now part of the modern [my emphasis] brewery property was granted to Richard Cole, who lived in Kilcreene' which later became the home of the Smithwick's family. Tellingly to my mind, Halpin goes on to say that 'there is no evidence available as to how [a] mercantile partnership between Messrs. Cole and Smithwick progressed.' It is worth pointing out here that Halpin worked for the Smithwicks brewery, and he skips forward in his piece on Kilkenny brewing to the site that was acquired by Edmund Smithwick in 1827, as I have mentioned above.

Yet another source is Iorwerth Griffith's book that I mentioned above. The chapter on the Smithwick's brewery mentions the Cole/Smithwick lease but states that 'that there is no mention of brewing in the document' with some authority, which of course does not mean that there was not brewing happening on the site at this time, but it seems like the author had first-hand knowledge of the original document.

In 2013 Art Kavanagh published a book on the history of the Smithwick family, and in it he states that the John Smithwick who allegedly founded the brewery in 1710 was a protestant (and descended from a military family with origins in Hertfordshire and with Cromwellian connections) until marrying his second wife and from then the family became catholic although the author seems to think that John may not have converted, although his gravestone is in St. Canice's Cathedral graveyard -it is quite visible with an archaic spelling of Smithwick. It was John's grandson - also called John and discussed above - who was involved in importing and exporting businesses and bought estates in and around Kilkenny, becoming quite wealthy and well regarded according to the Kavanagh. As I have already stated, this does not sound like a person who had a secret brewery that was set up by his grandfather. I would expect that if this later John owned a brewery he would have announced it to all, as the Penal Laws that were supposed prevent catholic from owning land, etc. seemed to have little effect on his standing or ability to do business, although I do not doubt it may have had some effect on parts of it and they are certainly not to be dismissed lightly. (To remind you again of the confusing timeline, it was Edmond the son of this second John who bought the distillery and converted into a brewery in 1827, as we have already discussed and as is confirmed by the author of this book.)

Very tellingly is a talk given by Walter Smithwick at Kilcreene Lodge to the Kilkenny Archaeological Society and published in 1960 which states that, 'Just before 1710 a young John Smithwick came from Tipperary to Kilkenny and started his business in the year 1710. Unfortunately, there are no records to show his precise business at that time.' [My emphasis.] He goes on to say that, 'In 1706 a Richard Cole of Kilcreene obtained a fee farm grant from James, Duke of Ormonde, of [a] portion of St. Francis Abbey Brewery.' Absolutely no reference to a connection with John Smithwick is mentioned, and the Smithwick's did not come into possession of the house for many years after. Straight from the horse's mouth it seems ...

John (Edmond's father) Smithwick's house on High Street in Kilkenny was to be let according to an advertisement in The Kilkenny Journal, and Leinster Commercial and Literary Advertiser of the 6th of July 1836 and is described as a place where there was carried out 'an extensive trade and which was lately rebuilt in a very substantial manner' and it contained 'a large and commodious shop, parlour' and other rooms - including eight bedrooms! Again, does any of that sound like a person who would need to be secretive about owning a brewery regardless of any remnants of penal laws that remained? 

So where exactly was the property leased by Richard Cole in 1705? Most sources give the impression it was close to the old brewery site, just off of what is now Parliament Street and therefore implying that there was a continuation of brewing on the site from around that period to when the brewery closed in this century. But there some issues with this if we look at the actual lease details, which we can via the Virtual Record Treasury of Ireland, which has a transcript of the original deed in its archives recorded by John Lodge (1692–1774) the deputy keeper of the records in Dublin Castle which reads:

Deeds of lease & release made 24 & 25 September 1705 whereby James, Duke of Ormand, for the sum of 40. 2. 8. Granted in fee farm to Richard Cole of Kilcreene, in [..] Liberties of Kilkenny,

Three thatcht [sic] tenements & gardens without [..] Black Abbey gate between the river & the city-wall.

To Hold as fully as the same were lately demised to Lady Evans, at the rent of 1£, two turkies [sic], or 5sh., receiver’s fees, & suit of courts & mills.

If we are unsure whether this is the actual lease in question there appears to be a more florid version of the lease on display in the Smithwick's Experience that can be seen and read in one of the images on this site. Apart from the additions to that one - or omissions of the one described above - we can see that they appear to be the same deed.

Three thatched cottages outside the Black Abbey gate (which still stands by the way) between the city walls and the river is quite easy to track down, as the walls and the river are easy to pinpoint and it has to be the Breagagh river that is being referred to, which flows into the Nore.

And here we can see the general site (red circle) on a map from c. 1780 – admittedly after the time of Cole – which show buildings in an area just outside the Black Abbey gate and between the walls and the river. Surely this is the site - or very close to it - given the description?

I have also placed an arrow at the end of the lane that leads to the Smithwick’s brewery site in the top picture, which is 200 meters away and across what was then the Coal Market. Not exactly close given the compact size of the city to anyone familiar with the city.

Another lease may exist but I have not found one, and as mentioned above it sounds identical to the one exhibited in the Smithwick's Experience - unless there is another there. Was there ever a brewery on this site near the Black Abbey? I do not know but I can find no reference to one in common sources.

There is no doubt that the Penal Laws did prevent Catholics from holding certain positions, property, etc. and it would certainly have prevented certain aspects of trade. I am not expert enough on this part of our history to dig very deep into how well it was enforced or not, and indeed a John 'Smithwith' [sic] from Kilkenny signed a petition that was published in The Dublin Evening Post on the 17th January 1792 imploring the authorities to rescind some of the barriers to trade, so it is important not to dismiss these laws entirely but certainly something does not seem right about the reason why the early generations of the Smithwick’s needed to be so secretive

We can see that there is no doubt that our John, the grandson of the alleged originator of the brewery, became quite a wealthy man during his lifetime and was certainly a well know public figure who owned or leased property in the city. A question that occurs to me is if he was in fear of the penal laws, as presumably was his father and grandfather, would they have risked the wrath of the authorities just to brew what was surely a moderate amount of beer? And surely at some point, given the cut-throat business ethics of the time, someone would have told the same to the authorities?

So to sum up, given the available evidence I can find nothing to say that the Smithwick’s were brewing prior to 1827. That there was a John Smithwick in Kilkenny in 1710 there can be no doubt, and he may have formed a partnership with a Richard Cole but I can find no evidence of either party brewing anywhere, although brewing for home consumption could certainly have taken place on various sites, perhaps even Archer's Grove which was owned by Richard Cole but is nowhere near the modern brewery site. I can only find evidence that the brewery dates from 1827 and the first beers brewed in the Smithwick’s name were brewed in that year or the following one. It is quite possible that the John Smithwick from 1710 did indeed form some sort of business but it seems unlikely given what I have researched that it anything to do with commercial brewing.

So I will leave the reader to decide if they think that a brewery owned by anyone in the Smithwick's family existed from 1710 ...

---

The Smithwick family appear to have been good, kind and generous people - perhaps more needs to be made of that and what they gave to the community of Kilkenny - and it is worth pointing out that many of the legends grew and took flight after their period of ownership of the brewery and the brand had finished. There are many interesting tales and probably even some fun frivolous stories that could be told about the people who owned, brewed in and worked in the brewery which can be based on facts, such as Edmond saving a child from drowning in 1841, and a large eel stopped the brewery from operating in 1921, or how a cavalcade of 53 drays loaded with porter and ale made its way from the brewery and onward by train to a ship, all destined for the export market. Although there have been less positive reports too, such as a boycott of Smithwick's beers proposed by the Irish National League in the late 1880s due to a tenant's rights issues. Any of those facts plus many more that I have found could at the very least be printed on some beer mats ...

And we could listen to real interviews from those who worked on the brewery site, we could taste the actual old brews like that Pale Butt and a Smithwick’s porter, or their famous and popular 19th century IPA. There are endless real possibilities to what could be told about this inspirational and interesting brewing company. 

Wouldn't that be a better Experience...?

Liam K.

(1st and 3rd image are from the author's collection, the 2nd and 4th are via Ebay beer mat sellers.)

(Old map of Kilkenny is via Wikimedia Commons here.)

All written content and the research involved in publishing it here is my own unless otherwise stated and cannot be reproduced elsewhere without permission, full credit to its source, and a link back to this post. With thanks to The British Newspaper Archive (www.britishnewspaperarchive.co.uk), Virtual Record Treasury of Ireland, and Google Books from where I accessed much of the content.